Considering Unemployment

December 16, 2009

Students consider our 10% unemployment rate from a numerical, social and emotional perspective, including through photos from the Great Depression.

Objectives

 
Students will:
  • explore unemployment on a numerical, social and emotional level
  • connect a historic period of high unemployment (the Great Depression) to today's situation
  • discuss how unemployment affects people/families across time and place
Social and Emotional Skills:
  • empathy/understanding the difficulties faced by families impacted by unemployment
  • putting a human face on unemployment statistics being used in the media
  • stepping into the shoes of those struggling with the consequences of unemployment
 
Materials needed
  • Today's agenda on chart paper or on the board 
  • Handouts of the images of unemployment included below
     

Gathering

(5 minutes)

 
Explain to students that you'll be doing a word association go-round. As the teacher, start sending the word around the circle by saying "unemployed" to the student on your right. That student will respond to you with their association, e.g. "poverty" then turn to the student on their right and say the word "unemployed" to elicit that student's association. The student will respond with his/her association, e.g. "hungry," before turning to the student to their right with the word "unemployed" once more.
 

Review agenda

(1 minute)
 
Explain that today's lesson will deal with unemployment (joblessness) through a variety of activities.
 

Today's unemployment in numbers

(10 minutes)

 
Introduce the lesson by drawing on some of the students' word associations and talking about the severity of the unemployment situation in the US today: More than 7 million Americans have lost their jobs since the recession began two years ago. As of December 2009, 10% of Americans were officially unemployed—a figure that President Obama called "staggering." What's more, the 10% number doesn't include those who have stopped looking for work or have settled for part-time employment when they wanted to work full-time. If these people were included in the numbers, the unemployment rate would reach 17.5%
 
So what do these numbers really mean? Ask your class to imagine that they represent the entire US population available for work. Assuming your class represents 100%, how many students would be unemployed if you used the government's statistic of 10%? What about if you used the broader measure of unemployment at 17.5%? When your class has worked out the number of students at 10% and 17.5% ask them to show it visually by having first 10% of your class stand up and then adding the additional 7.5%.
 
Ask students to look around and share what they think about these numbers. What do they think the impact is on a) the country b) communities, and c) individuals?
 

Yesterday's unemployment in images

(20 minutes)

 
Tell students that the current recession has brought back memories and references to the Great Depression of the 1930s. In fact, this recession is by several measures the worst since the Depression.
 
Ask students: What do students know about the Great Depression?
 
Share with them that the Great Depression was a worldwide economic crisis in the decade before World War II. Like today's recession, the Great Depression originated in the United States. It started with the stock market crash of October 29, 1929, and spread quickly, with devastating effects. Cities around the world were hit, especially those dependent on heavy industry. Construction practically came to a halt. Farming and rural areas suffered as well, as crop prices fell by approximately 60%. As international trade plunged, so did personal income, tax revenue, profits and prices.
 
A general loss of faith in the economy led to reduced levels of spending and demand, which contributed to the downward spiral. In the US alone unemployment went up to almost 30%. Breadlines stretched for blocks. There was a run on the banks and many financial institutions failed. In most countries the negative effects of the Great Depression continued for a decade until World War II.
 
Ask your students to consider some or all of the following photographs (either online or by printing them out for students to look at). The photographs are taken from the Franklin D. Roosevelt Library, courtesy of the National Archives and Records Administration. They are images of the Great Depression.
 
 
 
 
 
Consider using some or all of the following questions to get students talking about the photos:
  • What do students see in these pictures?
  • What do students see that speaks to them of unemployment? 
  • How do they think the people in the pictures feel? Why?
  • What picture speaks to them the most? Why?
  • How do they think these pictures relate to what is happening to people today?
  • Are there similarities with today's unemployment situation?
  • Do they think people who are affected by unemployment today feel the same way?
  • Can students relate to any of the people in the pictures? How?
  • Do they know of people who have lost their jobs or are afraid to lose their jobs? If so, what are their lives like?
  • Photo # 5 is probably the most famous photo of the Great Depression. Why do you think this is?
 
Additional Great Depression photographs for your students to consider can be found at: http://history1900s.about.com/od/photographs/tp/greatdepressionpictures.htm The collection includes pictures of the dustbowl, which forced many farmers from their land and of migrant workers - people who had lost their jobs or farms and traveled in search of new work.
 

President Obama's Next Steps

(10 minutes)

 
In his speech to the nation on December 8, 2009, President Obama stated: "We avoided the depression many feared" but "our work is far from done." Obama called for an additional burst of federal spending to jolt the wobbly economy into a stronger recovery and reduce persistent double digit-unemployment.
 
Republicans criticized the president, saying his proposal would further increase the U.S.'s large federal deficit. But some progressives argued that his proposal didn't go far enough (http://progressive.org/node/138424/2570).
 
President Obama proposed new spending for highway and bridge construction, for small business tax cuts and for retrofitting millions of homes to make them more energy-efficient. He said he wanted to extend economic stimulus programs to keep unemployment insurance from expiring for millions of out-of-work Americans and to help laid-off workers keep their health insurance. He proposed an additional $250 apiece in stimulus spending for seniors and veterans and aid to state and local governments to discourage them from laying off teachers, police officers and firefighters.
 
Ask students: What do you think about the government spending money to help boost the economy through job creation?
 

Closing

(4 minutes)

 
Ask a few volunteers to ask one thing they learned from today's lesson.
 
Alternatively, do the same word association you started the lesson with to see if anything shifted for the students as a result of today's lesson.
 

 


Homework

 
According to the Library of Congress website:
 
"The photograph that has become known as 'Migrant Mother' [photo #5] is one of a series of photographs that Dorothea Lange made of Florence Owens Thompson and her children in February or March of 1936 in Nipomo, California. Lange was concluding a month's trip photographing migratory farm labor around the state for what was then the Resettlement Administration. In 1960, Lange gave this account of the experience:
 
"'I saw and approached the hungry and desperate mother, as if drawn by a magnet. I do not remember how I explained my presence or my camera to her, but I do remember she asked me no questions. I made five exposures, working closer and closer from the same direction. I did not ask her name or her history. She told me her age, that she was thirty-two. She said that they had been living on frozen vegetables from the surrounding fields, and birds that the children killed. She had just sold the tires from her car to buy food. There she sat in that lean- to tent with her children huddled around her, and seemed to know that my pictures might help her, and so she helped me.'"
 
Ask students to step into the shoes of either the mother or one of the children in the photograph and write a paragraph or poem their experience, based on some of the dialogues in your class today.
 

This lesson was written by Marieke van Woerkom for TeachableMoment.Org, a project of Morningside Center for Teaching Social Responsibility. We welcome your comments. Please email us at: info@morningsidecenter.org